Desko vs. EyeOS
I was very happy with the progress I made on Desko today. I can successfully log into GMail and retrieve a list of my emails without downloading the entire inbox. It took me a little while to find the problem and it was quite simple in retrospect. I also made things work a little better while I was at it. I was generally feeling very pleased with the project when Corey sent me a link to eyeOS. It’s an open source online desktop written in PHP. It’s much further along than Desko and has a little community as well. It’s not exactly what I was shooting for but something very close no doubt. I plan to keep working on Desko as I see some differences in our approach. eyeOS seems to want to recreate a bunch of different apps and store them locally. Desko’s purpose is to integrate different apps together. Sure eyeOS is capable of such things but it isn’t the focus from what I gather. Also, I think Desko should be taking a distictively different direction in that it needs to focus on social networking. I want a taggable filesystem and I want to be able to share everything. Not just my files but my instances of webapps and my whole Desko instance if i want. I want to create a community of users and have Desko be the app that allows them to share among themselves. Desko is more than just a dumby replacement of the traditional desktop. Its a way to integrate and organize everything we do. It isn’t just an isolated individual running isolated apps but members of a community communicating and sharing data among themselves via Desko. That data can come from local or remote apps. The idea is to integrate it all together.

March 28th, 2006 at 12:51 pm
Don’t forget goowy, youos, fold, chimpos, gogui and all the rest…
March 28th, 2006 at 1:16 pm
I completely agree. Netvibes is yet another.The thing is, most of those you listed look like companies. One reason I started Desko was to allow users the freedom to control their own data. They can install Desko on whatever server they want and won’t have to pay for it other than hosting. I haven’t looked too much into them yet but I suspect they are recreating the wheel each time. They most likely build their own apps to do everything. So they’ll build their own mail app and their own word processor. I don’t envision recreating these apps. I just want to interface with existing apps, hense the GMail plugin. The one thing that I am creating from scratch is the taggable filesystem. I want ultimate control over my files so hosting my own filesystem makes sense. I’ll create a new post once I get the filesystem up and running.